More transparency in the video evidence - error in the Supercup 2

More transparency in the video evidence – error in the Supercup

More transparency, more cameras and a so-called "3-split" for viewers – CCTV, which is still criticized by many football fans, should be better. But already at the Supercup, everything did not go as planned.

Cologne (dpa) – The presentation of future progress in video evidence began with a description of the recent accident.

While DFB and DFL informed on the sidelines of a workshop bringing together club representatives in Cologne with the future developments of technology introduced two seasons ago in the Bundesliga, the protagonists began by putting themselves on the defensive.

Referring to a misbehavior of the video assistant of the Supercup, they commented on the decision criticized by many observers, according to which the international football Joshua Kimmich had only seen yellow after his fault against the professional Dortmund Jadon Sancho.

"In reality, the video assistant should have asked the referee to watch the scene on the monitor itself, which did not happen. The technical implementation did not occur. so was not correct, we would have liked the opposite, "said Jochen Drees, DFB. Project Manager for Video Assistant.

The Munich back had sent the shot to Englishman Sancho in the 76th minute during Bayern's 0-2 defeat. However, many observers have described this scene on the outer reddish line. Similarly, Lutz Michael Froehlich, athletic director of the elite referees: "He does not hit him with great momentum but without control over the foot." It is technically classified as a field reference.

Drees promised an improvement and did not think too much about dramatizing the incident: "Such a thing can happen, but it's not a major drama, it was 2-0 in Dortmund and this is n & # 39; Did not affect the match, but of course we will have to work on this stage. "Not without pride, he evoked the overall positive trend seen in video recordings over the past season:" We have prevented 82 decisions wrong, which is great for me. "

All participants worked hard to improve the Bundesliga 2017/18 and this year also in the lower house of football presented video evidence. In this way, a faster flow of information should provide more transparency in the future. In the future, compact textual explanations on the screens immediately inform stadium visitors about why the video assistant has been activated and on the scene being checked. For viewers, the same information is available via a so-called base signal in graphical form, which may be used by DFL media partners.

In addition, new camera perspectives should make the work of video assistants more understandable. Thus, the viewer receives an order called "in 3 parts", on which we can see both the scene to be controlled and the referee on the screen, as well as the video assistant of the cellar of Cologne. This should help to better understand on what visual basis the arbitrator makes his decision. "Since everyone looks at home, in principle, the arbitration television," said Ansgar Schwenken, director of the German Football League (DFL).

The rules adopted in early March by the Council of the International Football Association (IFAB) and the World Federation of FIFA also help to minimize bad decisions in the future. In particular, the clarifications made to the interpretation of the game of hands are used by referees as a tool for decision-making. "Overall, more cases are now explicitly described and clearly clarified, but there will always be disputes," commented DFB instructor Lutz Wagner.

DFB information on video evidence